Skip to main content
CallTally

Sample data — real records arrive after the first data run

Call record for @sample_value_vik

Value Vik

Hit rate, 1 month

60%

of 10 scored calls, 90% interval 35–81%

Record for @sample_value_vik at each horizon
HorizonHit rateExcess return vs SPYScored Calls90% interval
1 week60%−0.4%1035–81%
1 month60%+3.1%1035–81%
3 months25%−4.2%89–54%

Sample figures computed from fictional calls, measured against SPY over the same window as each call. No data run has happened yet.

How calls are scored

The link unfurls as this record's card: hit rate, excess return vs SPY, scored calls, the 90% interval and the methodology address.

How to read a record

Hit rate
The share of scored calls with a positive excess return in the direction of the call.
Excess return vs SPY
How far the stock beat or trailed SPY over the same window, counted in the direction of the call and averaged across scored calls.
Scored calls
Calls old enough to measure at that horizon. Newer calls join as their window closes.
90% interval
A Wilson score interval: the range the true hit rate likely sits in, given how many calls there are.

Scored calls

10 calls in date order, oldest first. Each one quotes the original post.

  1. INTC, Long

    Stated horizon 3 months

    Long $INTC. Trading below book with the foundry optionality for free.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the INTC call from Sep 3, 2025, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week−0.8%−1.5%Miss
    1 month−2.3%−0.7%Miss
    3 months−0.7%−7.9%Miss
  2. PFE, Long

    $PFE long here. The yield is paid for and the pipeline is better than the price says.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the PFE call from Sep 24, 2025, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week+2.9%−0.6%Miss
    1 month+12.9%+7.0%Hit
    3 months−0.3%−2.1%Miss
  3. VZ, Long

    Stated horizon 3 months

    Buying $VZ. Boring, cheap, and the dividend is covered.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the VZ call from Oct 28, 2025, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week−0.3%+0.9%Hit
    1 month+3.5%−1.5%Miss
    3 months+1.6%+4.2%Hit
  4. BABA, Long

    Long $BABA at 9x earnings. Too cheap to ignore.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the BABA call from Nov 25, 2025, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week−1.3%+1.0%Hit
    1 month+12.6%+9.6%Hit
    3 months−3.4%+4.1%Hit
  5. WBD, Long

    Stated horizon 3 months

    $WBD long. Free cash flow yield over 20% at this price.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the WBD call from Jan 13, 2026, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week−3.8%−4.8%Miss
    1 month+2.8%+3.4%Hit
    3 months−0.7%−7.1%Miss
  6. CVS, Long

    Starting a position in $CVS, long. The market is pricing in a disaster that isn't coming.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the CVS call from Feb 18, 2026, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week+3.0%+0.1%Hit
    1 month−3.4%+1.2%Hit
    3 months+1.2%−4.0%Miss
  7. SNOW, Short

    Stated horizon 3 months

    Short $SNOW. 20x sales for slowing growth is not value at any stage.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the SNOW call from Mar 24, 2026, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week−1.3%+0.1%Hit
    1 month−8.0%+8.1%Hit
    3 months−1.9%−2.1%Miss
  8. F, Long

    Long $F. Single digit P/E and the EV losses are shrinking.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the F call from Apr 28, 2026, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week+2.2%+1.2%Hit
    1 month−0.1%−1.6%Miss
    3 months−15.9%−18.4%Miss
  9. MMM, Long

    Stated horizon 3 months

    $MMM long after the spinoff. Sum of the parts is well above this price.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the MMM call from Jun 2, 2026, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week−2.9%−0.7%Miss
    1 month−1.6%−3.8%Miss
    3 monthsWindow still open
  10. BMY, Long

    Long $BMY. Cheapest big pharma on forward earnings.

    Posted by @sample_value_vik at
    Scores for the BMY call from Jul 21, 2026, measured against SPY over the same window
    HorizonStockvs SPYResult
    1 week+0.8%+0.5%Hit
    1 month+9.5%+9.1%Hit
    3 monthsWindow still open